A Lesson in Modesty.
One afternoon a long time ago, when I discovered that the Stankles’ daughter had left her wet “M” on the condominium elevator floor (see my essay, “The Mark of Mordechi”), I also noticed another troubling pattern taking shape.
About a week later, as she walked through the lobby, this twelve‑year‑old was dressed in a way that was startlingly immodest for a child her age. What shocked me was not merely the barely-there-bikini itself, but the contradiction behind it. An exposed belly button with floss for bottoms and the top just covering the nips. That’s it.
Her father is a “preacher” in a community fellowship. Her mother teaches in a Christian school. One would expect that parents who publicly live a life of Sunday preaching and Christian schooling would guide their own children toward modesty, dignity, and respect for themselves and others, particularly since it’s all laid out in the Bible.
If these parents claim to follow God’s laws, which includes the call to modesty, why is their daughter being sent into public areas dressed in ways that undermine or ignore those very teachings?
It was hard not to miss the wide disconnect. The preacher man and his wife presented themselves as righteous leaders in public, yet the example they set within their own household tells a very different story. They were rude and cold around people when it’s only them without the others, but the moment another Stankle appeared beside them, the transformation was instantaneous. Suddenly it was All Christian, All the Time: doors held open, cheerful greetings, syrupy small talk, and enough forced sunshine to blind a person. As a group, they radiated a kind of performative wholesomeness. Alone, each one reverted to something far less Christian.
It does not come across as practicing what is being preached with a “Glory Halleluiah” on the stage every Sunday and Wednesday.
That is the deeper sorrow of it all; when those who are entrusted with shaping young souls fail to live the very virtues they proclaim, the child becomes the one who bears the confusion. A home that should be a sanctuary of positive formation instead becomes a place of mixed messages. I prayed that Maddee grows into a someone who has a clearer understanding of modesty and faith, and that her brother follows the righteous way, too. But even more, I pray that her parents rediscover the integrity their public roles demand. For the sake of their daughter, and for the sake of the witness they offer to the rest of us, I hope they all find their way back to the truth they profess and convert.
