BOOK REVIEW: A Little Florida Lady

It never fails that when I start researching for one thing, I come across something else that takes me down another road, then to something else again that may or may not be related to the first thing I was researching, and then I wind up with something new and exciting that I never dreamed at the start.

“A Little Florida Lady” is that “something new and exciting” discovery.

I came across this 1903 children’s story by Dorothy C. Paine while I was researching life in the Old South and plantation living for a separate writing project. One thing led to another, this book came across my radar, and I decided it might be worth a read.

The little Florida lady is Beth Davenport, a native New York little girl, who moves to Florida with her family. She experiences new sights and sounds, odd flora and fauna, and a different way of life and vernacular along the way, beginning with the train trip to Jacksonville, Florida, and then beyond to their new home in the South.

Paine uses dialect to perfection when the black characters speak. And to buttress the dialect, she describes the black characters in terms that today would be considered in bad taste. How times have changed! However, as long as the reader understands that this story was published in 1903, dialect and descriptions work well together. In fact, I found that I could easily visualize the characters and scenes because of that. It was real.

There are lessons in this story, though awkward and perhaps judgmental in today’s mind and thinking, yet are very good ones. For example, let’s look at this scene:

Beth loved to travel, and soon was on speaking terms with every one [sic] on the car. She hesitated slightly about being friends with the porter. He made her think of the first colored person she had ever seen. She remembered even now how the man’s rolling black eyes had frightened her, although it was the blackness of his skin that had impressed her the most. She believed that he had become dirty, the way she sometimes did, only in a greater degree.

“Mamma,” she whispered, “I never get as black as that man, do I? Do you s’pose he ever washes himself?”

Mrs. Davenport explained that cleanliness had nothing to do with the
man’s blackness.

“Is he black inside?” Beth questioned in great awe.

“No. All people are alike at heart. Clean thinking makes even the
black man white within, dear.”

Beth’s mother gently explained to her, in so many words, that people are people, no matter their outward appearance – a sort of “we are all God’s children” lesson.

We see a new world as Beth sees it. Cotton fields looked like “little specks of white [looking like] little balls of snow . . . on bushes.”

Beth sees Spanish moss on live oaks as “hair.” She compares new things to those she knows, and she has that feeling and reaction of awe:

She was impatient to see everything . . . She felt that she needed a thousand eyes. The trees bewildered her. There were so many varieties she had never seen before – magnolias with their wonderful glossy foliage; bamboos with their tropical stalks covered with luxuriant green; pomegranates; live-oaks and water-oaks; the wild olive with its feathery white blossoms, and many others.

Beth makes friends at her new home, including the ubiquitous chubby, happy, red kerchief-wearing, apron-toting black woman found in many Southern stories. Yes, it’s typical and almost expected in these old stories, but I remained unphased about it – after all, this “typical” character’s name was Maggie, and that was a nice change from – brace yourself – Mammy.

Pierce’s use of dialect works well, albeit with the vernacular at the time this story was written:

As Mr. Davenport and Beth walked to the side of the darky, he lifted
his stovepipe hat that had been brushed until the silk was wearing
away. He revealed thereby a shock of iron-gray wool. He made a
sweeping bow.

“Massa, am dis de little missy dat yo’ wuz tellin’ ’bout? I’se powerful glad to meet yo’, missy.”

And that is how the reader is introduced to the Davenport’s driver, January.

Pierce continues the stereotypical descriptions of people, but it’s almost unnoticeable since it is the story:

Beth returned to the barn with Duke. January as usual was idling. He
had his fiddle and was playing “Dixie.” Beth sat down on the hay near
him, while the dog family frolicked around her. She was happy, so
happy that from sheer light-heartedness she began to sing.

Along the way, Beth meets and befriends blonde, blue-eyed poor white trash Gustus, who helps to expand her new Southern world. He exposes her to fishing, and teaches her a lesson about alligators, which she thought at first were dragons.

All in all, “The Little Florida Lady” is a good read, and one that can be finished inside of a couple of hours. As long as the reader understands the timeframe in which this story was written and the thinking of people back then, it becomes a positive, learning-lesson type of story that can be applied today in various ways, despite the mischievousness of it.

As Pierce wrote about Beth’s recovery from an illness, we can possible apply our own recovery from the illness of injurious prejudice today:

With the elasticity of childhood, Beth grew well rapidly, and was once
more her mischievous self.

How elastic are we today, in a world vastly different than in 1903 when this book was published, in regards to anything that is negative? We can learn that while we can bounce back from the condition of misunderstanding and prejudice, we can also become our mischievous selves again. The point to ponder is, are to become mischievous in a playful and impish sense, or mischievous in a malicious and wicked sense?

You can find a free copy of this book in electronic format at LoyalBooks.

“A Little Florida Lady”
By Dorothy C. Paine
Copyright, 1903, by
George W. Jacobs & Company
Published, October, 1903

Pages: 156


The original book cover.

©Susan Marie Molloy, and works within.


About Susan Marie Molloy

I am an observer, a writer, and a poet. My latest poetry books, "Indigo Fantasy," "Life in the Oasis," "Gallery Night," "God of the Sea," and "Grapes Suzette" and my short stories, "The Green Gloves" and "The Crowd of Turin" are now available on Amazon. Check them out. Buy them. Read them. Send me your thoughts. I look forward to hearing from you. View all posts by Susan Marie Molloy

2 responses to “BOOK REVIEW: A Little Florida Lady

  • GP Cox

    Sounds great for the kids. An interesting story to get the children more interested in reading.
    I know that feeling of researching one thing and coming up with another!!!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Susan Marie Molloy

      I would imagine this book would have been a great adventure for kids back then. Today, everything’s is immediately accessable, particularly over the Internet, so alligators and Spanish moss and people who spoke “different” would have been exiciting. This really was a sweet book. It’d made a nice movie, too. And speaking of movies, that’s how I find the most obscure ones: Look up A, find B, and oh wow! C is something I never heard of; let’s watch! 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Reading, Writing, Hearing and Tasting the Art of Life

What's for Dinner Moms?

Creativity for my life.

Les souvenirs de guerre de Gérard Pelletier

Disparu depuis le 3 septembre 1942


Short Stories by Barry Wax

Frank Frisson

Fiction and Non-Fiction Reviews

the enagmatic girl


Susan Feathers

Online Home of Author and Educator

Blabber 'n' Smoke

A Glasgow view of Americana and related music and writings.

Lit World Interviews

Share and Spread the Word About These Authors!

© The Secret Poetess

Her secret verse & other offerings...

Adam Padilla

Films and TV


A blog by Dr. Abhinav Majumder

Little Fears

Tales of whimsy, humour and courgettes

Smorgasbord - Variety is the spice of life

Blog with a view - on books, music, humour and health

Ankit Mishra

Smile! Because You're Beautiful.. :)

The Critiquing Chemist

Literary Analysis derived from an Analytical Chemist

The Curious Guy

Abhijeet's Blog

Dear Colleague

Tales at the Water Cooler

Roy F. McCampbell's Blog

A Commentary On Life

Mystery Thriller Week

Celebrate the Annual Event


Covering All of Pre-Code Hollywood Cinema, 1930 - 1934


Sometimes I feel like I am just WINGING IT, but then I remember... I can do this, by GRACE.


Vague Meanderings of the Broke and Obscure

History Myths Debunked

The Whole Truth and Nothing But the Truth


Discovering the Conspiracy

The Vintage Traveler

Fuzzylizzie's Fashion & Travel: Vintage Style

All Things Georgian

Super Sleuths who blog about anything and everything to do with the Georgian Era

A Hundred Years Ago

Food and More

Annika Perry's Writing Blog

Join me as I edit my first novel and aim for publication

Attila Ovari

Loving Life and Inspiring Others

Life in the Realm of Fantasy

The writerly musings of Connie J. Jasperson, author, blogger and medieval renaissance woman.

Comet Over Hollywood

Home for classic movie lovers

Dan Alatorre - AUTHOR

helpful writer ramblings from a disturbed mind just like yours

Broadway Fillmore Alive

The Online Voice of East Buffalo's Historic Broadway-Fillmore Neighborhood

The Chicago Files


The Year(s) of Living Non-Judgmentally

Here and now, with all of it.

Susan Finlay Writes

Susan Writes Mysteries and Suspense

Notes from the U.K.

Exploring the spidery corners of a culture and the weird stuff that tourist brochures ignore.

Bluefish Way

The life of Ralph, Natascha and our cats

The Silent Eye

A Modern Mystery School

✨The Fairy Whisperer ✨Colleen Chesebro✨

YA Fantasy Novelist, Poet, & Visual Word Artist

Kate M. Colby

Soft Sci-Fi, Dark Fantasy & Nonfiction Author

%d bloggers like this: