Susan Marie Molloy

🌺 Life in the Oasis 🌴

BOOK REVIEW: All Hallows at Eyre Hall


I'm a member of Rosie's Book Review Team.

I’m a member of Rosie’s Book Review Team.

BOOK REVIEW: “All Hallows at Eyre Hall” by Luccia Gray
By Susan Marie Molloy

I’ll cut to the chase:

All Hallows at Eyre Hall by Luccia Gray is exciting, masterfully written, and left me cheering for, and sometimes scowling at, all the characters within, while gleefully enjoying the twists and surprises of the story and character development.
When we left off with Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre in the 1840s, Jane was pretty much a blasé, spineless jellyfish in a sea of scandal and mysteries. The Byronic Edward Fairfax Rochester was morally bankrupt with an insane first wife, and overall, he was not as nice a man as Jane would have been lead to believe. What has become of Jane, Edward, et al?

Luccia Gray picked up the story in All Hallows at Eyre Hall. We find it is two decades later, in 1860s England, and Jane is stronger; she is a busy, modern, mature woman within a difficult marriage to the still-despicable Edward. Jane realizes that Edward’s failings and infamous perverse past – illegitimate issue included – leads her to no longer loving him, and yet, although outside circumstances entice her towards a happier life without him, she at least publicly remains steadfast as his devoted wife. Privately, yet inappropriately, she falls in love with a much younger man. Edward’s brother-in-law, Richard Mason (brother of Edward’s first wife) returns, and he attempts to wheedle his way into the estate.

All Hallows is believable and well-written, true to the “voice” of Brontë, and well-researched. In fact, at times I thought Charlotte Brontë was writing this; that is how fabulous a writer Luccia Gray is. This is not to say that she is a copy-cat writer. No, the author understands and “gets” the flavor, feel, and construction of Brontë’s work – an honor to a classic author, and thus, that is how sequels should be written. Bravo!

Written as a rotating narrative, the reader will find the richness of each character’s soul, perception, and thoughts conveyed in the first person. Indeed, my favorite chapter that reflects a breathless and soulful first-person narrative is “The Funeral.”

I especially enjoyed references by the characters within All Hallows to contemporary events and literature. Within the pages we correctly discover that Alfred, Lord Tennyson, is Queen Victoria’s favorite poet laureate. Oliver Twist by Charles Dickens is discussed by the characters (though the novel was published about fifteen years before All Hallows events), and mention was made of David Copperfield. This is real life between the fictional pages.

All Hallows is peppered with French phrases and sentences. This is wonderfully placed and true to novels written at the time of Brontë, et al. It is not unusual to read English language books published at that time that are interleaved with French. Educated writers and readers were well-versed in French, so to see and read it within English-language novels was not uncommon.

Luccia Gray is a beautifully descriptive writer. I sensed a need to don my wool cape when she wrote: “ . . . the horizon is grey, the air smells of damp weeds, and the wind is cold and furious . . .” I felt the almost imperceptible warmth on my face when “ . . . the sun . . . was suddenly visible, pale and low on the distant horizon.” Through her descriptions, I was there – right there.

On All Hallows Eve (Hallowe’en), several characters related ghost stories that intrigued me. I felt I was there in the room with them, nighttime with tallow candles burning and throwing otherworldly shadows across the walls. The cakes baked and eaten during All Hallows reflect the custom of placing certain colored buttons within, portending the future of each person who finds one in his slice. These events wonderfully relate old customs not seen much since.

Within the chapter, “A Letter from the Past,” the author brought me to early mornings at Eyre Hall. There is the perfectly-described organized morning with servants preparing breakfast, cleaning, and the mistress of the estate busying herself with accounting books and writing letters. I found myself re-reading this portion to revel in the clear images brought to my mind.

There was only one sentence early in the novel that confused me and caused me to re-read several times to understand its meaning: “Mothers should not spend too much time with the male siblings, as they soften their minds . . .” I thought the word “sibling” should be “offspring” or “child” or some such familial label. I thought Edward was discussing his distaste for Jane’s devotion to their son, not a brother, as I understood the sentence.

Overall, All Hallows at Eyre Hall by Luccia Gray is an exquisitely written, well-researched, and well-conveyed continuation of Jane Eyre. I am anticipating the next novel, Twelfth Night at Eyre Hall, which is due out this fall.

I give five brilliantly shining stars out of five to All Hallows at Eyre Hall by Luccia Gray.

© Susan Marie Molloy and all works within. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material and any works here on this site without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited.


Author: Susan Marie Molloy

Hi, and welcome to my blog. I am a published writer, poet, photographer, freelance editor, artist, and career analyst. Growing up in a bilingual family helped me foster my love of languages. I hold a Bachelor of Arts degree in History and Political Science, a Bachelor of Arts degree in English, and Master of Arts in History. My short stories, poetry, and photographs have been published in the Emerald Coast Review (18th and 19th editions), newspapers, and in many other publications. I enjoy Pre-Code films, photography, music, travelling, history, reading, and living each day to the fullest in The Oasis. My publications include Engaged (an anthology of my poems), The Crowd of Turin, God of the Sea: A Short Book of Poetry by the Seashore, Grapes Suzette and Other Poetic Epicurean Delights, Gallery Night, Indigo Fantasy, The Green Gloves, Puppy Love, Supreme Theater, and others. I am currently working on an anthology of my short stories, including a roman à clef tale, and am in collaboration with another artist in writing a novel. My books are available through Amazon. Check them out. Buy them. Read them. Send me your thoughts. I look forward to hearing from you.

16 thoughts on “BOOK REVIEW: All Hallows at Eyre Hall

  1. A really great review, so glad you enjoyed the book.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. This is in my TBR pile. But believe it or not, I’ve never read Jane Eyre. Guess I need to read it first.

    Liked by 2 people

    • It’s been years since I’ve read “Jane Eyre,” so I remembered more of it as I read “All Hallows.” I think you could read the two out of sequence, but then, again, the second in Luccia’s trilogy, “Twelthfh Night” is due out soon, I believe — so somewhere I recommend you read Bronte’s novel. I’m sure you will like them all!


  3. I loved Jane Eyre and look forward to this read soon.

    Liked by 2 people

    • It’s been years since I’ve read “Jane Eyre,” so I remembered more of it as I read “All Hallows.” I think you could read the two out of sequence, but then, again, the second in Luccia’s trilogy, “Twelthfh Night” is due out soon, I believe — so somewhere I recommend you read Bronte’s novel. I’m sure you will like them all!


    • This is an outstanding novel. I can hardly wait for the next two in this trilogy. It’s rare that sequels are fabulous; Luccia is truly gifted. 😄
      I look forward to see what you and everyone thinks of the novels.


  4. Well, there another on my must read list.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. Susan, Thank you for such a wonderful review. I’m so glad you enjoyed it. I’ll look into the use of the word ‘sibling’. Thank you for pointing it out. I’m revising carefully (once more, does it ever end?!) to publish a paperback copy with CréateSpace.
    I also wanted to let anyone who’d like to read it to know that it doesn’t matter at all if you haven’t read Jane Eyre, before reading All Hallows at Eyre Hall, although you may want to read it after 🙂
    I’m planning to have it on offer on a free promotion over the Halloween weekend, very soon! to celebrate All Hallows, which is the time of year the narration takes place.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you, Luccia, for giving me the chance to read your work. It was wonderfully grand to read and get lost in another time and place.

      I agree that “Jane Eyre” doesn’t have to be read first. Your work in “All Hallows” fills everything in quite nicely so readers aren’t left with gaps. At some point, Bronte’s story should be read, though, so that the fullness is appreciated with Bronte’s style and your style, and the story is completely rounded out.

      I look forward to “Twelfth Night!”


  6. Pingback: BOOK REVIEW: “All Hallows at Eyre Hall” By Luccia Gray | Rereading Jane Eyre

  7. Reblogged this on Rereading Jane Eyre and commented:
    I feel very fortunate because Susan Marie Molloy has taken the time to read and write such a thorough and thoughtful review my novel. Check out Susan’s inspiring blog for other great reviews and much more! Thanks also to Rosie Amber who organises a great book review team!

    Liked by 1 person

  8. I heartily agree with the review as I am deeply engrossed in the book and thoroughly enjoying it! This is definitely a book to put at the top of your reading list.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I normally don’t re-read parts of a novel as I’m reading it, but this one I did, because I wanted to revel in certain beautifully-written scenes before moving along. Luccia really captured the characters and the era perfectly in mannerisms, daily life, and milieu. 🙂


      Liked by 1 person